Court Experience
Published decisions provide a public record of Dr. Jesse De La Cruz's involvement and the courts' treatment of particular proposed opinions. This selected archive includes both favorable and limiting rulings. Qualification, scope, and admissibility remain specific to each proceeding.
United States v. Graham
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit · December 2, 2024 · No. 19-10332
Role: Proposed defense gang expert. The district court excluded his testimony in its entirety.
The appellate majority found that wholesale exclusion erroneous. Its analysis addressed proposed testimony concerning the alleged gang and enterprise and rejected the grounds offered for excluding all of it. The decision set aside the Count 1 RICO conspiracy convictions and sentences of six defendants and remanded for a new trial if the government chose to retry them.
Limits: The opinion does not establish that every proposed statement was admissible. A judge dissented from the expert-testimony holding. The appellate ruling is a judicial decision, not an outcome produced or guaranteed by an expert witness. The opinion also resolves other issues separately.
Read the official opinion · Expert discussion at printed pages 71–94; disposition at printed pages 138–139.
United States v. Williams
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit · September 10, 2020 · Consolidated appeals including No. 18-1012
Role: Defense expert who interviewed twelve defendants and proposed an assessment based on eight characteristics developed during his gang research.
The district court permitted an overview of gang activities but restricted application of those characteristics to the defendants. The Third Circuit found no reversible error in that restriction. It explained that a RICO enterprise may exist without being a gang and that gang membership by itself does not establish RICO conspiracy. The court identified the risk of confusing those distinct questions.
Limits: This is a limiting ruling, not an example of unrestricted admission. Its treatment of the proposed criteria illustrates why an expert's research must be connected carefully to the legal and factual issues in a particular case.
Read the official opinion on GovInfo · Discussion at printed pages 52–53.
Reported qualifications in context
Graham reports more than 60 expert qualifications in federal and state courts and consultation in more than 500 additional matters. These are historical figures reported in the 2024 opinion. Prior qualification is not a standing credential that binds another court.
This archive summarizes the cited decisions. It does not represent a complete litigation history or a current docket check. Counsel should read the full opinions and assess subsequent developments before relying on them.
Explore expert witness services or request a consultation about your matter.
